Aluminum PCB Drill & Router Bits: Uncoated vs DLC vs PCD Diamond-Coated

APPLICATION GUIDE  /  PCB TOOLING

Aluminum PCB cutters should be selected around the problem on the production line: aluminum buildup, burrs, edge wear or frequent tool changes. The coating name alone does not tell you which tool will produce more acceptable holes or a longer usable routed edge.

This guide compares uncoated carbide, DLC-coated and PCD diamond-coated drill and router bits for aluminum substrate PCBs. It is written for process engineers, tooling buyers and suppliers reviewing samples for an end customer.

In this guide

Confirm the board and the cutting operation

An aluminum-based metal core PCB typically combines a copper circuit layer, a dielectric layer and an aluminum base. Depending on the operation, the tool may contact the aluminum alone or cut through several layers. A result obtained in solid aluminum is therefore useful background, but it does not reproduce every PCB construction.

Drilling

Record the hole diameter, board or stack thickness, entry and exit quality, and support under the board. A drill removes material primarily in the axial direction.

Routing and slot milling

Record the slot or contour, cutting depth, routed-edge requirement and chip-removal method. Lateral cutting also requires suitable peripheral geometry and board support.

Some purpose-designed drill-point routers can perform both operations. Confirm their end geometry and permitted entry method; a matching diameter does not make an ordinary drill and router interchangeable. For a broader geometry overview, see our PCB drills and router bits selection guide.

Aluminum PCB cutters: compare the three options

Use the comparison below to choose a sample candidate. The final result depends on the carbide substrate, edge preparation, flute geometry, coating quality and cutting conditions.

Choose a sample by the production issue. Coating names alone do not establish a performance ranking.
Coating option When to evaluate What to check in a trial Decision to make
Uncoated carbideCost baseline Current quality and tool-change frequency are acceptable. Geometry, edge finish and cutting data; accepted output and tool-change frequency. Keep it if output meets the requirement at an acceptable cost.
DLC coatedAdhesion trial Aluminum buildup affects cutting stability or chip flow. DLC type, thickness and adhesion; edge buildup and interruption frequency. Change if fewer adhesion-related interruptions justify the added cost.
PCD Diamond-CoatedWear-resistance trial Progressive wear causes burr growth or dimensional drift. Diamond film specification, adhesion and edge condition; accepted output before replacement. Change if extra accepted output offsets the price premium.

Uncoated carbide: establish a useful baseline

Uncoated cutters can be a sound choice for short or moderate runs when dimensions, burr levels and replacement frequency already meet the requirement. Record their accepted output before paying for a coating upgrade. An inexpensive cutter that works consistently may remain the most economical choice.

DLC coated: evaluate when aluminum adhesion is the main issue

DLC is a family of diamond-like carbon coatings, rather than one universal specification. Its low-friction and anti-adhesion potential makes it a candidate when aluminum builds up on the cutting edge or obstructs the flutes. Compare actual edge buildup and cutting stability; surface color alone does not establish coating type or quality.

PCD Diamond-Coated: evaluate when wear limits production

PCD Diamond-Coated carbide is worth reviewing when progressive edge wear reduces acceptable routing distance or hole count. Confirm that the coating, edge preparation and geometry suit the board and operation. A wear-resistant coating cannot compensate for unsuitable entry geometry, poor support or overloaded flutes.

Terminology: HY Cutting Tools uses “PCD Diamond-Coated” as a product-version designation for its diamond-coated cutters. This does not mean the cutters have brazed or sintered PCD cutting tips. Confirm the precise coating structure from the product specification.

Choose around the problem you can observe

Use the timing of the defect to narrow the next trial.
What happens in production First checks Sample candidate
Aluminum builds up on the edge Edge condition, chip space, chip removal and cutting data DLC with an appropriate aluminum-cutting geometry
Burrs appear with a new tool Tip and flute geometry, cutting direction, support and entry/exit conditions Correct the process or geometry before assuming a coating problem
Burrs grow during the run Inspect progressive wear and record when the quality limit is reached Compare a PCD diamond-coated candidate with the current tool
Tool changes interrupt production Separate wear from breakage, chip packing and handling damage Compare accepted output and total tool-change cost
Uncoated cutter already meets the target Record accepted holes or routing distance and unit cost Retain the baseline unless an upgrade pays for itself

Burr formation is not a coating-only problem. The same visible burr can come from a worn edge, an unsuitable cutting direction, poor support or unsuitable parameters. Inspect both the tool and the board before changing several variables at once.

DLC and Diamond Coatings in Aluminum Drilling

These two studies examine coated drills in solid aluminum alloys. They provide background for choosing trial tools; PCB layer construction and routing conditions still need to be checked separately.

STUDY SETUP / 2022

DLC on carbide

Workpiece

Al–Si alloy

High-speed drilling

Friction and wear
Coating adhesion
Hole quality

Study summary graphic

MARTINS ET AL. / 2022

DLC-coated carbide drills in Al–Si alloy

Martins and colleagues examined DLC on carbide tools for high-speed drilling of an Al–Si alloy. They combined coating characterization and friction-and-wear tests with drilling tests that assessed hole quality at different cutting speeds.

The friction tests showed a reduced coefficient of friction and resistance to abrasive wear. The machining tests reported smaller changes in hole quality across the tested cutting speeds. For sample selection, the study supports checking coating adhesion, friction and hole quality together. It does not establish a fixed tool-life increase.

2022 DLC drilling study — publisher’s abstract

Wear, 498–499, 204326.
DOI: 10.1016/j.wear.2022.204326

STUDY SETUP / 2015

Coated microdrills

MCDNCDDLCTiAlN

Workpiece

Al7075

Comparing coating types
and diamond film thickness

Study summary graphic

LEI, SHEN & SUN / 2015

Diamond-coated microdrills: coating type and thickness

Lei, Shen and Sun compared MCD, NCD, DLC and TiAlN coatings on microdrills used in Al7075. In the comparison after 200 holes, NCD-coated microdrills gave the best cutting performance among the tested coatings.

They then tested NCD film thicknesses of 1, 2, 4.5 and 7 μm. The 4.5 μm coating performed best in that experiment, with low flank wear and good hole quality. The useful purchasing point is to confirm the diamond film structure, thickness and adhesion; a thicker coating is not automatically the better choice.

2015 diamond-coated microdrill study — publisher’s abstract

Diamond and Related Materials, 54, 79–90.
DOI: 10.1016/j.diamond.2014.11.003

Compare cost per accepted hole or routing meter

Purchase price becomes meaningful when it is divided by acceptable output. Define the quality limit first: maximum burr, dimensional deviation, unacceptable finish or another agreed replacement criterion. Count only output that meets that limit.

Drilling

Cutter price ÷ accepted hole count

Routing

Cutter price ÷ accepted routing length

Hypothetical purchasing example only — not HY test data or a promised tool life.
Illustrative drilling example Uncoated cutter PCD Diamond-Coated cutter
Purchase price $10 $30
Accepted holes 1,000 5,000
Direct tool cost per accepted hole $0.010 $0.006

In this example, a cutter priced at three times the baseline produces five times as many accepted holes, reducing direct tool cost per accepted hole by 40%. At three times the price, it would need at least three times the accepted output just to match the baseline direct tool cost.

For a production decision, also account for tool-change time, inspection, rejected boards and machine downtime. For contour routing, use accepted routing length rather than hole count. A coating upgrade is justified when the measured benefit exceeds the additional cost.

Use sample trials to verify the aluminum PCB cutter

Agree on the comparison before machining. Use the current tool as the baseline and test a candidate against the same acceptance criteria. Where geometry requires different settings, record those settings separately so a parameter change is not mistaken for a coating-only effect.

Identify the board and operation

Record the aluminum grade if known, layer construction, board thickness, number of panels in a stack, and whether the tool cuts the metal alone or multiple layers.

Match the critical tool details

Confirm cutting diameter, flute length, shank, overall length, tip shape, cutting direction, entry method and positioning ring. A brand/model, drawing or readable packaging label is a useful starting point.

Record the actual cutting conditions

Log spindle speed, feed, cutting depth, chip removal or lubrication, holder condition, runout and board support. Photograph the new edge and the board before changing the setup.

Apply the same replacement criterion

Inspect dimensions, edge quality, burrs and wear at comparable hole counts or routing distances. Record repeat results across more than one cutter where practical; one unusually good or poor tool is a weak purchasing baseline.

Use this record for a sample report or an alternative-supplier review.
What to record Drilling Routing
Dimensions Hole diameter and consistency Slot or profile width
Burrs and finish Entry/exit edges and hole condition Routed-edge burrs and finish
Usable output Accepted holes per cutter Accepted routing meters per cutter
Reason for replacement Quality limit, wear, breakage or another recorded cause Quality limit, wear, breakage or another recorded cause

If you supply tools to an end customer, you can begin with their current model, dimensions, quantities and problem photographs. Missing board or machine information can be confirmed during technical review rather than guessed from the coating name.

Frequently asked questions

Will DLC coating solve burrs on an aluminum PCB?

It may help when adhered aluminum is part of the cause. Burrs can also come from geometry, cutting direction, poor support or wear. If burrs are present with a new tool, review those conditions before treating the coating as the only variable.

Does PCD Diamond Coating Last Longer Than DLC?

No universal ranking can be made from the coating names. Compare the actual film, edge geometry, board and process using the same quality limit. A longer wear interval is useful only if the accepted output offsets the additional cost.

Is a PCD Diamond-Coated Cutter the Same as a PCD-Tipped Cutter?

No. Here, PCD Diamond-Coated is HY’s product-version name for its diamond-coated carbide cutters. It does not refer to a separate sintered PCD cutting tip. Confirm the coating specification and construction when ordering.

Can an alternative cutter replace an established brand?

It can be evaluated for the application after dimensions, end geometry, cutting direction, coating and machine compatibility have been reviewed. Matching diameter alone does not establish interchangeability. Use a controlled sample trial before changing an established production tool.

What do you need to recommend a sample?

Send the existing model or drawing, cutting diameter and length, board material and thickness, current machining problem, quantity per size and positioning-ring requirements. Include parameters and photographs if available.

Review a sample for your existing application

HY Cutting Tools supplies uncoated, DLC-coated and PCD diamond-coated aluminum substrate PCB drill and router bits. Standard dimensions, custom sizes, with-ring or ringless options, mixed-size orders and OEM packaging can be reviewed against your requirements.

Send your current model or a clear tool photograph, the dimensions and the issue you want to improve. We can review suitable sample options before a bulk order.

Product dimensions and coating options  ·  Custom cutting tools

Related guides

How to choose PCB drills and router bits

How to choose PCB drills and router bits

Review the operation, tool geometry, board construction and information needed for a useful RFQ.

Machining troubleshooting guide

Machining troubleshooting guide

Check the setup, chips and wear pattern before choosing a different cutter.

Technical references and scope

Academic studies: Martins et al. (2022), Wear, 498–499, 204326, DOI 10.1016/j.wear.2022.204326; Lei, Shen and Sun (2015), Diamond and Related Materials, 54, 79–90, DOI 10.1016/j.diamond.2014.11.003. The publication links appear beside the relevant findings above.

Published studies are supporting information, not HY test results or guaranteed product performance. Verify any proposed cutter through samples on the actual board, machine and acceptance criteria.